Lawn Herbicides PAR III®, Trillion, and Threeway
A Comparative Analysis of Nearly Identical Products under Different Brands
The lawn herbicide industry offers a variety of products aimed at controlling broadleaf weeds, and some of them share identical active ingredients. Three notable herbicides, PAR III® Turf by Loveland, Trillion Turf Herbicide by Nufarm, and Threeway Herbicide, are all formulated with a combination of common active ingredients: 2,4-D, mecoprop-p (MCPP), and dicamba.
PAR III® Turf by Loveland:
PAR III® Turf is a creation of Loveland Products, a company dedicated to providing agricultural solutions and lawn management products since its foundation in 1985. The formulation of PAR III® Turf, with its three active ingredients, aims to offer a comprehensive solution for effective weed control in residential, commercial, and institutional lawns. It’s important to note that PAR III® Turf, like the other presented herbicides, has an identical concentration of active ingredients, establishing equivalency in efficacy.
Trillion Turf Herbicide by Nufarm:
Nufarm, a major player in the agricultural sector since 1960, manufactures Trillion Turf Herbicide. Trillion, belonging to herbicide group 4, presents a liquid formulation containing specific concentrations of 2,4-D, mecoprop-p, and dicamba. This herbicide is particularly suitable for weed control in various environments such as pastures, meadows, and golf courses.
Threeway Herbicide (Premium 3-Way XP) by IPCO:
Threeway Herbicide, also known as Premium 3-Way XP, is formulated by IPCO, a Canadian company dedicated to creating agrochemical and pharmaceutical solutions since 1992. IPCO is committed to providing high-quality products to meet the needs of the agricultural industry. The formulation of Threeway Herbicide combines three active ingredients, namely 2,4-D, MCPP, and dicamba. This combination offers effective control of broadleaf weeds in lawns, golf courses, and other turf areas.
While these herbicides share identical active ingredients, the difference may lie in the base components, also called “fillers” or formulation agents. These components can influence various aspects such as the concentration of the product’s odor and adhesion. Some users have noted differences in odor, with suggestions that Trillion may have a slightly stronger odor than PAR III®. However, some prefer PAR III® for its less pronounced odor.
According to users’ personal experiences, nuances have been observed in the effectiveness and application of these products. Trillion, despite its similar concentration of active ingredients, seems to demonstrate slightly superior effectiveness, especially against stubborn weeds like violets. However, it’s important to note that Threeway Herbicide requires a more delicate application to avoid residues on asphalt surfaces, due to its petroleum base. This consideration is crucial for preserving the aesthetics of treated spaces.
In conclusion, if you are pondering the choice of which product to use, the primary consideration might be the availability in stock rather than relative efficacy, as all these herbicides present an identical concentration of active ingredients, ensuring equivalency in effectiveness regardless of the brand. It's essential to consider these personal observations while carefully following the manufacturer's recommendations to ensure optimal use of each product in specific conditions. Remember that the choice often boils down to availability, with all three products offering similar performance.